FREE

Knowledge is the key to a better, healthier you. So why not sign up to receive all our posts by email for Free!

Enter your email address:

We will not pass your information on to anyone else

Recent Comments

Home > 2008 > 09 > 16 > Why is Cooking with Oil bad for you?


Why is Cooking with Oil bad for you?

Beeble wearing his science outfit ready to work out why cooking in oil can be bad for you.This is where you will need to don your lab coats because beebleblog will now turn into a bit of a science lesson. Hopefully we will able to keep it more interesting than the science lessons we all remember (or not in some cases – Beeble).

There is a widely held belief that goes like this “When heating the oil when cooking you are in fact starting your own chemical experiment where unsaturated fat (good fat) becomes saturated (bad fat)”. If you are one of these people that are using oil in your cooking (olive or sunflower) you may be cooking away thinking you are being healthy by choosing olive oil, however this is not the case when heating is involved.

What are oils?

Quite simply oils are fats. Whilst fats are generally solid at room temperature oils are liquid. Fatty acids are part of the makeup of fats and oils and it is their structure that decides the flavours, textures and melting points. It is also the fatty acids that decide whether the fat or oil in question is a saturated or unsaturated fat or, in other words, good or bad fat.

What are Fatty Acids?

Fatty acids are simply a chain of carbon atoms all holding ‘hands’ and it is how they hold ‘hands’ that determines how the fat behaves. (Still with us or have we managed to send you to sleep yet? – Beeble).

What are Saturated Fats?

Saturated fats (bad fats) are usually solid at room temperature and in their natural form are normally from animal sources, e.g. butter and lard. The picture below shows the saturated fatty acid and you should notice that all the carbon links are indeed either linked to another carbon atom or a hydrogen atom. Each carbon atom has 4 ‘arms’ that need to be joined to another atom. In this case you can see that all the carbon atoms are joined to another atom and this is what saturated fat looks like, all the carbon atoms are saturated with another atom.

molecular structure of saturated fat

What are Unsaturated Fats?

Unlike saturated fats, unsaturated fats are usually liquid at room temperature and come primarily from vegetable oils and oily fish. The picture below shows the make up of a mono unsaturated fat and the immediate difference is that not all the carbon links are joined to a hydrogen atom. There are two carbon atoms that are linked to each other and these change the properties of the fat to a liquid at room temperature. Good examples of mono unsaturated fats are olive oil, rapeseed oil, peanut oil and avocado. This type of fat is much better for you than the saturated fats.

molecular structure of monounsaturated fat

Polyunsaturated fat

Below is a diagram of another unsaturated fat’s molecular make up. This fat is known as polyunsaturated fat and the difference between this and the mono unsaturated fat is that there is more than just one carbon atom link not connected to a hydrogen atom. Good examples of polyunsaturated fats are sunflower oil and corn oil.

molecular structure of polyunsaturated fat

I hope we haven’t lost you yet because it is about to get interesting and to the point of this post.

Why can unsaturated fats (good fats) be bad for us?

Unsaturated fats can be “cis” fats or “trans fats”. “Cis” fats are natural and would be found in good quality cold pressed olive oil and unheated this oil can be very good for our bodies. “Trans” fats have been in the news a lot lately and were recently banned from cooking in a few selected areas in America. However this hydrogenated fat (forces those free carbon atoms in the unsaturated fat diagrams to hold ‘hands’ with hydrogen) is not only found in cooking at fast food restaurants but it is also found a little closer to home like in hydrogenated margarines.

molecular structure of cis fat

molecular structure of trans fat

The “cis” fat can be converted to a “trans” fat through a process called hydrogenation and also heating. It is this heating that should make you realise where I am going with this. When we think we are being healthier by choosing olive oil to cook with because of its health benefits, we are over looking the fact that the heating involved in cooking is actually changing this healthy fat to a trans fat which over time is detrimental to our health.

What is hydrogenation?

This is a process used by companies like margarine manufacturers to change liquid oils (good oils) to solid oils (bad oils) and requires a nickel catalyst (nickel is used to make the chemical change take place, but it does not appear in the end result). This means that the original unsaturated fat now becomes solid at room temperature and is now saturated and unhealthy for our bodies. The margarine companies found that partial hydrogenation allowed them to make their butter replacement easier to spread. Whilst it is not fully hydrogenated it is still a trans fat and very bad for our bodies.

What’s wrong with heating oils?

Trans fat can also occur when good fats are heated over a period of time and instead of using nickel as a catalyst it uses oxygen which all our homes have in plentiful supply. The heating of the oil starts a process called oxidation which has the same effect as partial hydrogenation and forces the carbon atoms that are joined to other carbon atoms to join with hydrogen atoms instead. This of course makes the oil become more saturated and therefore worse for our health.

What can you do?

The advice is easy: avoid frying foods as much as you can and instead grill your food which involves no extra oil or fat, or use a griddle pan which also requires no oil or fat. If you do need to use oil still use a good quality oil but don’t just pour it in like you were filling your car up; instead wipe the oil over the surface of the pan to prevent any sticking. The less you use the better!

You may have also noticed the mention of margarine and that it is made using the hydrogenation process which raises a whole new subject about how good margarine is for you. The advice though is similar; try not to use it and when you do please use it sparingly.

Like nearly all foods that are bad for you it often takes large quantities over long periods of time to cause health problems. The trick is to treat yourself to these foods and not make it a regular event. If you suffer from high blood pressure, are overweight and/or have high cholesterol then my advice would be: make a drastic change now and ban the bad oils, fats and other foods that are making your situation worse. The only way you will improve your health is to make the change now.

We wish everyone trying to make a change to their lifestyle all the best and success with their journeys.

Bookmark and Share

Related posts




8 Responses to “Why is Cooking with Oil bad for you?”

  1. Maggi Says:

    Great post! Great explaination! Great Website! Thanks… keep up the excellent work!

  2. L Paul Says:

    I’ve read several articles contradicting this article in regards to olive oil. How do you know who is correct? My sources are well documented physicians. These sources state that home cooking will not cause this to happen. Any comments appreciated!

  3. Hugo Says:

    Hi,

    Many thanks for you comment on beebleblog.com, I was hoping I wouldn’t have to put my science cap back on so soon after this post. However I agree with you it is a confusing point and one that is difficult to research. The problems come when you look at the different boiling points of oil (sounds boring) but the different boiling points decide when the saturation reaction happens. So the theory is that a quick fry in olive oil is actually not unhealthy at all because the oil is not given time to change. It is in fact very difficult to get high saturation levels from home cooking but it does happen to a level. It has to as there has to be a reaction but it is not as unhealthy as deep fat fryers used in fast food cooking.
    My point is that however small the reaction it is still not healthy to cook in olive oil and it is much better to bake or to grill. So if you are still frying your food don’t worry too much but like with everything it should be done in moderation.

    I hope this helps answer your question and if I can be of any further help please just ask. Enjoy beebleblog.com

    Many thanks

    Hugo

  4. steve Says:

    I heard that rapeseed oil is better than olive oil for cooking, since it has a higher boiling point. Does it make a real difference at the temperatures you are likely to cook at home?

  5. Britney Says:

    I’m doing an essay on trans fat for my Eng 313 class, and when I came to this piece of information about homecooking turning into trans fat cooking I was confused and asked my anatomy professor. Heat may break some double bonds in an unsaturated fat and result in a random reconfiguration of the double bond to be in the trans position. However, the amount of trans fats created this way are much, much less than the number created under high pressures and high temperatures with a nickel catalyst.
    This idea that some trans fats are created by heat alone (of an unsaturated fat) has been an argument proposed by raw vegans for their diet lifestyle. However, I suspect that the danger of picking up bacteria from the raw food is probably a greater health risk than consuming the few trans fats from heating unsaturated fats. Considering the intense process commercial trans fat goes through, with extremely high pressure and heat, I doubt that the minimal time and heat used while cooking with unsaturated fats will do much of anything when it comes to health.

  6. hugo Says:

    Thank you Britney. It does seem to be a fact that if you do use oil in your cooking the amount of trans fat created is not as bad as the margarine process or fast food cooking. However it does still create some and in my book even some is bad especially over a long period of time. When we have options like grilling it seems sensible to steer clear of any frying or roasting where possible.

  7. Danny Says:

    Like everyone else, I used to cook with oils. Then in 1995 I stopped cooking with oils and my health improved dramatically ! How can oil be good for our health when a tablespoon of oil contains roughly 12 grams of fat ?? If you add 3 tablespoons of oil to a salad, you’ve added the same amount of fat as found in a McDonalds Big Mac. The type of fat from the oil is irrelevant. Fat is fat and it will settle around your stomach. You don’t believe me ? Try it. Oil is a fat and that’s bad.

  8. Sean Says:

    The last post is plain wrong. Sorry Danny, but you don’t have your facts straight…EFA’s (essential fatty acids) are very good for you and promote fat loss. That is why fish and avocados (in moderation) are part of a very healthy diet. Not all fats are the same – and to say that 3 tbsp of olive oil is equivalent to a Big Mac in terms of health implications is grossly negligent.

Leave a Reply


Subscribe to our feed
Follow Beeble on Twitter

Archives